91av

Letters archive

Join the conversation in 91av's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


8 October 2025

Carbon storage is a bit of a distraction

From Paul Broady, Christchurch, New Zealand

Are we really going to store thousands of gigatonnes of carbon dioxide in geological formations? There are real doubts about whether the required technology will become sufficiently developed and whether the energy needed for it would be available. At present, only a few million tonnes per year are being pumped underground and much of this …

8 October 2025

A pessimistic view on climate targets

From Vincent Flood, Evanston, Illinois, US

Some views on global warming targets reveal a continuing fantasy: the belief that any such target is achievable without climate engineering. Nobody, their governments included, is going to tell people in low-income countries that they can't have air conditioning or cars (or toasters, microwave ovens, etc.). Global warming is unstoppable, and the adverse consequences will …

8 October 2025

Geoengineering is going to be very challenging

From Jim McHardy, Clydebank, West Dunbartonshire, UK

Drilling through polar ice to pump out liquid water from beneath won't work for several reasons that weren't mentioned. At the depths and temperatures of the buried water, it is close to the equilibrium between being ice or water. A slight change could drive it either way. Water, whether in an artesian well or pumped …

8 October 2025

On the search for life beyond Earth

From Eric Kvaalen, Les Essarts-le-Roi, France

When astronomers say that, sooner or later, we will come across an exoplanet with a nitrogen/oxygen-rich atmosphere, or that, by 2060, we are likely to have discovered planets where it is hard to explain the data without there being life, they are assuming, with no good reason, that life can easily arise if the conditions …

15 October 2025

The long history of superluminal motion

From Peter Holness, Hertford, UK

I have read your fascinating article on the phenomenon of superluminal shadows in astronomical contexts. It is truly captivating to explore these cosmic curiosities. However, I would like to point out that apparent superluminal motion isn't just confined to the depths of space( 27 September, p 42 ). Engineering equipment capable of demonstrating similar effects …

15 October 2025

There are other factors to consider in living to 100 (1)

From John Bell, Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire, UK

In your look at how to live to 100, Bryan Johnson states that he doesn't need to worry about how long he will live because it won't be long before he can upload himself to an AI( 20 September, p 40 ). This is, of course, massively optimistic, requiring not only the technology, but also …

15 October 2025

There are other factors to consider in living to 100 (2)

From Peter Slessenger, Reading, Berkshire, UK

Why was there no mention of posture in "How to live to 100"? The typical depiction of older people is of someone bent over while using a walking stick, but good, upright posture aids breathing and mobility, and helps to avoid injuries when exercising.

15 October 2025

The paradox of being an otrovert

From Graeme Buckley, Wellington, New Zealand

I concur with Robert Sugden's views. As an otrovert, I find no particular attraction in interacting with others solely because they are also otroverts. Interesting conversations come from people with different points of view. I am Russell's paradox, part of a set that doesn't include myself( Letters, 13 September ).

15 October 2025

On the truth about narcissists (1)

From Matthew Stevens, Sydney, Australia

David Robson's article on narcissism is enlightening and a reminder that we can all get carried away with trying to appear cleverer than we are. But the final paragraph sidesteps the elephant in the room: we may well be better off without narcissists, but when we grant them power, they destroy lives and economies. Avoiding …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with 91av events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop