91av

Letters archive

Join the conversation in 91av's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


29 October 2025

A new way to think about mental illness (1)

From Ros Groves, Watford, UK

The fact that genetic developments linked to higher intelligence have been dated to around the time of a sudden explosion in the making of more complex tools would appear to be more than a coincidence( 18 October, p 6 ). What was required in a tool? How and where it would be used? How it …

29 October 2025

A new way to think about mental illness (2)

From Joe Lewis, Falmouth, Cornwall, UK

I have bipolar disorder. In the modern world, that is often very unhelpful, particularly during hypomanic episodes. However, in a hunter-gatherer society, I could see these episodes having an advantage. You could stay up all night to watch out for danger. Even the hallucinations that come with psychosis may have been seen as important to …

29 October 2025

On the crime and punishment debate (1)

From Jon Atack, Nottingham, UK

Thank you for Raihan Alam and Tage Rai's excellent article on how society punishes people. The Mendota Juvenile Treatment Center study showed that offenders who received counselling did far better than those who didn't. The science shows that kindness leads to a better outcome for all concerned( 18 October, p 19 ).

29 October 2025

On the crime and punishment debate (2)

From Dave Neale, Bedford, UK

Throughout humankind's history, we have had to get used to taking high risks simply in order to eat. If it didn't take risks, the tribe starved. Humanity has evolved to live with risks as a part of normal life. So the idea that criminals are deterred by the fairly low risk of being caught and …

29 October 2025

On the crime and punishment debate (3)

From David Aldred, Brough, East Riding of Yorkshire, UK

On the main subject of untethering punishment from profit, I think the easiest way to remove any perception of authorities fining people in order to fill financial holes would be to fine them and burn the money. Then the criminal would be punished but the punisher wouldn't profit.

29 October 2025

Ghosts and spirits in the marshes

From Jim McHardy, Clydebank, West Dunbartonshire, UK

As your article states, it is very likely that will-o'-the-wisps are caused by the ignition of methane or phosphine when bubbles of these merge( 11 October, p 19 ). High-speed propellers and pumps are affected by cavitation when the blades are travelling so fast that bubbles of vapour appear and collapse very rapidly. This violent …

29 October 2025

Life in plastic is not at all fantastic

From John Healey, Semaphore, South Australia

I read with concern that research scientists have developed a stronger, tougher plastic. Why? Plastics contribute massively to greenhouse gas emissions, pollute the oceans and kill wildlife. We should be phasing out plastics, not inventing more( 4 October, p 12 ).

5 November 2025

Let's hear it for the horror fans (2)

From Daniel Dresner,<br/>Manchester, UK

I don't recognise the profiling of horror film fans suggested by Scrivner. There is a missing category: the staple thrill of hoping – or at least trying to work out – which character survives the zombies, razor-sharp pendulums, or the end of life as we know it, rather than morbid curiosity. I'd put myself in …

5 November 2025

The solution to the carbon-capture conundrum?

From Eric Kvaalen,<br/>Les Essarts-le-Roi, France

David Flint is right that we need to remove carbon dioxide from the air in order to keep the world at a good temperature. The easiest way to do this, in my opinion, is to harvest biomass. The biomass can be stored as it is or transformed into another form, like charcoal, or even burned …

5 November 2025

Revenge never tasted so sweet

From Peter Slessenger,<br/>Reading, Berkshire, UK

I cannot help feeling that making coffee with beans from civet "scat" was originally done for revenge, bullying or a joke. My guess is that a disliked manager, or annoying colleague, was given a cup as a joke or a dare, and surprisingly, really liked it( 1 November, p 17 ).

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with 91av events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop