Letters archive
Join the conversation in 91av's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com
26 November 2025
From Andrew Whiteley, Consett, Durham, UK
Elle Hunt gives a positive review of Christine Webb's book The Arrogant Ape , which aims to demolish the myth of human exceptionalism. Yet it is the case, for example, that while we hold people morally accountable for their actions, we don't do this with other animals. This suggests that human exceptionalism may not be …
26 November 2025
From Denis Watkins, Truro, Cornwall, UK
Christine Webb offers a much-needed challenge to the "God made man in his image" view and its consequences. The myth persists in various forms despite humans continuing the wrecking of the planet and the extinction of its creatures. The Homo sapiens name is richly ironic for what might more accurately be described as the human …
26 November 2025
From Hans Jenks, Portland, Oregon, US
If I'm not mistaken, we are the fastest, strongest, smartest, most innovative, curious, talented species on the planet. With our incredible minds, we have made supersonic jets and Mars rovers, and harnessed the power of the atom. Meanwhile, chimps are still slinging poop at each other. Show us some respect. Admiration. Awe.
26 November 2025
From James Stone, Buxton, Derbyshire, UK
We can learn much about when to give up from the natural world. When a bee is collecting pollen, there is an optimal time to give up expending increasing amounts of energy, and deliver the pollen to the hive ( 15 November, p 28 ). Charnov's marginal value theorem states that if there are diminishing …
26 November 2025
From John Tons, Adelaide, South Australia
There have been a number of articles about geoengineering as a means of averting catastrophic climate change. It isn't so much a scientific problem but a political one. All solutions require global cooperation – something that remains elusive. However, guerrilla approaches can work! For example, we know shrinking icecaps mean less radiation is reflected back. …
26 November 2025
From Ken Appleby, Ledbury, Herefordshire, UK
Robin Asby misunderstands the essential difference between quantum and classical. In a quantum equivalent of his observation that his cat is sleeping in one of a number of possible places when he gets home, the quantum "cat" is in none of the locations until he observes it (or all of them, depending on which interpretation …
26 November 2025
From John Healey, Adelaide, South Australia
With regard to our inability to analyse consciousness, may I offer the following Gödelian observation? If our minds were simple enough to understand, we would be too simple to understand them.
3 December 2025
From Matt Black, Moreton-in-Marsh, Gloucestershire, UK
Jonathan R. Goodman argues that the selfish gene view of evolution is correct and bemoans the "old and tired" debate on whether niceness and group selection trump that. It is this binary thinking that is old and tired. Evidence for each view exists and must be synthesised into a 360-degree view. Competition and cooperation are …
3 December 2025
From Terry Klumpp, Melbourne, Australia
On the discussion of knowing when to give up on your goals, I contend that longing for perfection of oneself is an exercise in futility and frustration. Why? Because none of us is perfect and, despite our best efforts, alas, none of us will ever be perfect. Let's all relax a little and not set …