91av

UK’s plastic bag ban is a pitiful attempt at a greener future

Talk of cutting plastic pollution has grabbed the headlines, but the UK’s long-awaited 25-year plan for the environment consists almost entirely of vague aspirations and vacuous promises
Smiling Theresa May at a podium that says "A cleaner greener Britain"
Tough on plastic bags, but it’s not enough
Daniel Leal-Olivas/AFP/Getty

Prime Minister Theresa May today unveiled . It contains much talk about protecting wildlife, making the country cleaner and greener, and so on. It all sounds wonderful, but it is mostly waffle.

“The government’s 25-year environment plan is a monumental anti-climax,” the Green Party. “Nothing new, nothing of substance, nothing to tackle climate change.”

Take the plans to reduce plastic pollution, which dominated the headlines. A worthy goal, absolutely. But what will actually be done? A mandatory 5-pence charge for plastic bags will be extended to small shops as well as large ones. Plastic bag usage has already fallen nearly 90 per cent due to the 5p charge in large shops, so this is not going to make a huge difference.

It’s worth pointing out, too, that this charge was for reducing plastic bag consumption, rules that were opposed by May’s Conservative Party.

No substance

And that’s just about it. The plan states that “we want to eliminate all avoidable plastic waste” by 2042. But this is just a vague aspiration, not a legal requirement. And that weasel word “avoidable” makes it meaningless in any case.

What about climate change, by far the greatest threat to the environment? We are currently heading for a world about 4°C warmer, which would result in huge swathes of the UK disappearing under the waves and would utterly transform what countryside remained.

Here, the Conservative Party’s record is abysmal. After the party won an outright majority in 2015, the government scrapped a long list of policies designed to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, such as subsidies for renewable energy. The UK is no longer on track to meet its own emissions targets and it is likely to deviate even further off-course in the coming years as the effects of the cuts start to become manifest.

The claim at the time was that the scrapped policies were inefficient and would be replaced with better ones. Nearly three years on, we are still waiting. “We will take all possible action to mitigate climate change,” claims the 25-year plan. But again, there is no substance, despite there being a long list of steps that are absolutely crucial if the UK is to have any chance of meeting its climate targets.

No time to waste

For starters, the UK should stop blocking the construction of on-shore wind farms– it is the cheapest form of renewable energy. It also needs to come up with a coherent plan for improving the woeful energy efficiency of its housing, which will have the bonus of reducing people’s energy bills. In addition, it needs a plan for replacing fossil gas as the main source of energy for heating. This is going to take decades, so there is no time to waste.

New homes should have stringent standards – retrofitting is much harder and more expensive. And England and Wales should follow Scotland’s example and ban fracking – it is simply not compatible with meeting the emissions targets.

Then there is air pollution, which is so bad in the UK and many other countries that it will probably cut months off people’s lives. Reading this plan, you wouldn’t have a clue that the UK is not only still failing to meet EU standards that came into force in 2010, it still hasn’t even come up with a credible plan for meeting those standards.

Indeed, almost all the major improvements to the UK’s environmental regulations in recent decades, from clean beaches to plastic bags, come from the EU. “Brexit will not mean a lowering of environmental standards,” May claimed in her speech. But like just about everything when it comes to Brexit, this remains far from certain.

Article amended on 23 January 2018

We corrected the likely life-shortening effect of air pollution

Topics: Climate / Climate change / Environment / Politics / United Kingdom